Community-led initiatives are a powerful way to create sustainable change. They allow programs and projects to be developed and managed by people within the local community who understand their specific needs. Investing in these initiatives can help stimulate growth, impact, resources, and capacity on a larger scale. Furthermore, it gives communities an increased sense of ownership over their development and encourages projects that meet long-term goals. Supporting community-led work is an effective way to ensure lasting change within a society. Investing in local communities can help foster meaningful and sustainable transformation in the long run.
Although community-led initiatives often prove to be a powerful and effective way for community engagement to create meaningful impact. These grassroots efforts led by those in the local community can be an excellent avenue for fundraising, volunteer engagement, and shared knowledge on best practices. In addition, they are more likely to involve local stakeholders at all project stages due to their smaller scale, giving individuals more control and influence over the outcome. When supported by larger organizations or funders, these community-led initiatives can become even more robust and have greater reach and local development. By investing in local efforts to drive social change, we can help communities come together to create lasting impact.
Additionally, supporting well-structured community-led initiatives can provide access to resources and knowledge that already exists in the local context, creating a culture of collaboration and economic development instead of competition. In doing so, we can empower those on the ground to take ownership of their development while providing a platform for learning from each other. Ultimately this can lead to more sustainable solutions that address the root causes of problems rather than just treating their symptoms. Investing in community-led projects can help build strong, resilient communities. This can be a powerful way to catalyze social change and create lasting positive outcomes.
It is important to note that community-led practice can be challenging to distinguish. For example, some smaller and local organizations may need more core principles of such a practice. In contrast, some large international organizations may have more centralized decision-making power but can still incorporate these principles into their programming. Thus, it is vital for all types of organizations – large or small – to recognize the importance of community-led practice.
The National Initiative for Human Development (INDH) was launched in 2005 for empowering communities and to improve the living conditions of poor and vulnerable groups through enhanced economic opportunities, better access to basic and social services, and improved governance.
It assumes that people are their own assets, and the role of the external agent is to catalyze, facilitate or “accompany” the community in acquiring power. Community empowerment, therefore, is more than the involvement, participation or engagement of communities.
Technical assistance can also be an effective tool for empowering community development initiatives by providing individuals and organizations with the skills, knowledge, and resources they need to succeed.
Doing so will ensure that their overall strategy is more effective and in line with the community needs and of those they are serving. It can also lead to lasting, positive change within a community.
Ultimately, understanding how to incorporate community-led principles into organizational strategies is essential for creating meaningful, sustainable progress.
In this article, we explore the concept of a community-led initiative, examining its benefits and drawbacks. We also discuss how to evaluate such an organization and assess if it is appropriate for your philanthropic portfolio. If you are interested in further learning about building a philanthropic portfolio, be sure to read our related articles on our website blog as well.
What is a community-led initiative?
Community-led initiatives originate from and are run by the people they strive to serve. These projects and organizations believe that change is most effective when it comes from within, so they are driven by individuals who understand the needs of their area best. Such initiatives focus on creating meaningful and impactful social changes to better the community.
The ultimate goal of these initiatives is to empower communities and their give them the tools they need to create positive and lasting changes in their environment. External organizations often support community-led initiatives, but the local people take the lead in making meaningful improvements for their benefit.
Community-based initiatives typically involve small-scale projects and programs to benefit a specific geographic area. Examples of such economic empowerment efforts include food banks, cooperative farms, and community centers, all of which are aimed at providing direct assistance to local individuals and families. Such initiatives can have a tremendous impact on the local population, helping to ensure that everyone is provided with the resources they need to succeed. In addition, by engaging community members in these efforts, everyone can help contribute to the betterment of their area and those around them.
However, some of these communities have come together to form activist organizations. An example of this is March for Our Lives – a youth-led organization that emerged from protests after a school shooting in the United States. Here, ‘community’ is not only about geography; it can also be about shared values and identities, such as race, sexual orientation, or a shared experience like gun violence. These communities are connected by something much more profound than their physical location.
What are the benefits of a community-led approach?
The advantages of a community-led approach are becoming increasingly acknowledged, as communities have often proven to be the most capable of addressing and contributing to solutions for their issues (such as healthcare and pandemic response) and overall community well being. Participating in these initiatives can also provide an empowering and transformative experience for those involved.
When this approach is successful, it involves a shared vision specific to the local context that informs and guides the way forward. Then, utilizing existing relationships and resources, stakeholders can develop solutions that benefit the entire community.
The rise of community-led initiatives has been attributed to the critique surrounding traditional philanthropy. This approach, where outsiders enter a community without fully understanding local needs, has been particularly criticized in international development circles – the infamous Playpumps project being one example of many which resulted in millions of dollars being wasted due to assumptions about what would best benefit the community.
Local initiatives are more accountable than externally-run projects as contributors are embedded in the community and less likely to leave abruptly. This accountability allows for long-term, durable change that creates positive outcomes for those involved. In addition, community members who take ownership of local issues can be confident that their efforts will have a lasting impact on their community.
The involvement of community members in these initiatives also increases their understanding of the problem. In addition, it allows them to come up with more meaningful solutions that directly impact those affected. This leads to improved outcomes for the community as a whole.
Ultimately, community-led initiatives can effectively tackle local issues sustainably and create tangible results for communities in need.
The way forward is to ensure that local communities are provided with the necessary support they need to lead these initiatives to create meaningful change and lasting impact in their community. This includes providing access to resources such as funding and technical expertise so that projects can be implemented quickly and effectively. It also involves empowering community members to take the lead in making decisions and driving their initiatives, so they can be sure that their efforts have a positive impact.
By doing this, we can ensure that local communities have an effective platform to create meaningful change and make a difference.
What are the risks of a community-led approach?
We must be aware of the potential risks involved in a community-led approach. For example, if there are existing power imbalances within the community, these could be further entrenched through decisions and activities that may only benefit some members equally. In such cases, funding this type of initiative could even reinforce damaging inequalities.
While passion and lived experience are essential elements of running successful community initiatives, it is also necessary to bring specific expertise for effective organizational management. Such knowledge is required for the potential of these programs to be realized, and inefficiencies may occur. Therefore, more than relying on good intentions alone is necessary when managing a social agenda.
The Trussell Trust is tackling the issue of food insecurity head-on. Through their franchise model, they provide local food banks with the necessary resources and support to operate independently, allowing them to thrive in their respective and partner communities. This approach has proven successful in helping those in need get access to the food they need. This organization works hard to ensure that no one goes hungry. With their help, we can ensure that everyone has access to the nourishment they need. The Trussell Trust sets an example for other organizations and shows them how to address food insecurity effectively. Their work is critical in ensuring that people worldwide have enough food to eat. We can all do our part to help by supporting the Trussell Trust’s mission and contributing to the global fight against hunger. Together, we can make a difference.
Measuring the impact of community-led initiatives can be daunting, especially for small organizations. Resources such as time and money are often limited, and technical expertise may also be required. In these cases, evaluating impact to determine whether goals and objectives have been achieved can be difficult. However, in some instances, simple initiatives that target specific needs–like food banks–can be enough to effectively address issues like hunger in the short term, even if broader systemic change is still needed. Successful monitoring and evaluation of these initiatives are essential for determining their effectiveness.
It may be difficult to provide even a short-term solution for community-led initiatives that address complex issues such as mental health or gang violence. These approaches must have some cycle of evaluation and improvement built into them to measure their success.
How to recognize a strong community-led initiative
When considering whether to support a charity, it can be challenging to assess the quality of the initiative. However, the following tips can help you understand if a community-led initiative is strong:
- Look for evidence of local ownership and involvement. The best initiatives are those that are driven by community members of the society who have an in-depth understanding of the issues and needs of their area.
- Ask questions about sustainability. An effective community-led initiative should have a plan for long-term success, including strategies for funding, recruiting volunteers, and engaging with stakeholders.
- Evaluate the impact that an initiative has had on the local community. Ask questions about the results of their efforts and look for evidence of their activities having a positive, lasting effect on local people.
- Consider whether the initiative is well organized and managed. Look at their governance structure, financial processes, policies, and procedures to ensure that they are properly governed and transparent in their operations.
By considering these factors, you can ensure that your organization is investing its resources into a worthwhile and effective community-led initiative. With the proper support, these initiatives can have a significant impact on the local area and help to create lasting positive change.
Lastly, when selecting a community-led initiative to support, it is best to provide unrestricted funding. This will ensure the initiative can respond to the community’s needs without being limited by its donors. In addition, doing so will make the initiative more effective and successful.
Whether you’re a startup organization or a leading corporation, CommunityForce provides fully customizable, all-in-one online grant management solutions to maximize your efficiency, simplify complex processes, and improve collaboration so you can focus on increasing your impact. We’ve helped organizations streamline their entire process no matter the size and scope of their giving.